The Brutal Truth About Managing Emotions During Layoff Conversations: What 15 Years Taught Me About Doing the Undoable

Nobody teaches you in business school how to look someone in the eye and tell them their job is gone. Not really. They give you frameworks and scripts, but they don't prepare you for the moment when Sarah from accounts starts crying, or when Mark throws his security pass on your desk and walks out without a word.

I've been on both sides of these conversations more times than I care to count. As a workplace consultant who's helped organisations navigate everything from small redundancies to massive restructures, I can tell you that most leaders get this spectacularly wrong. Not because they're heartless, but because they're trying to be professional when what's needed is humanity.

The Myth of the "Clean" Layoff

Here's my first controversial opinion: there's no such thing as a clean layoff. Anyone who tells you otherwise has either never done it or is lying to themselves. Every termination leaves scars – on the person leaving, on their colleagues, and yes, on you as the manager delivering the news.

I learned this the hard way during the 2008 financial crisis when I was running operations for a mid-sized manufacturing company in Melbourne. We had to let go of 40% of our workforce over six weeks. The HR consultants we hired kept talking about "managing the process efficiently" and "minimising disruption to business operations."

What a load of rubbish.

The disruption isn't the point – the people are. Those first few conversations were disasters because I was so focused on following the script that I forgot I was talking to human beings with mortgages and kids and dreams that were about to get turned upside down.

The Emotional Rollercoaster Nobody Warns You About

Let me share something most executives won't admit: layoff conversations are emotionally devastating for managers too. You're dealing with your own guilt, fear, and often anger at the circumstances that led to this point. Then you're expected to somehow be the calm, composed leader while destroying someone's sense of security.

The range of reactions you'll encounter is staggering. I've had people:

• Thank me for being honest (still haunts me)
• Demand to know why it wasn't someone else instead
• Break down completely
• Get aggressive and threatening
• Just sit in stunned silence for ten minutes

Each reaction requires a different emotional response from you, and frankly, most of us aren't equipped for it. We're business professionals, not counsellors. Yet suddenly we're expected to navigate grief, anger, and despair with the same skill we use to read quarterly reports.

Where Most Leaders Stuff It Up

The biggest mistake I see managers make? Rushing through the conversation. They want to get it over with, so they deliver the news, hand over the paperwork, and try to wrap things up as quickly as possible.

Wrong approach entirely.

These conversations need time. Real time. Not fifteen minutes squeezed between other meetings. I now block out at least an hour for each layoff conversation, even though the actual discussion might only take twenty minutes. Why? Because people need space to process, ask questions, and sometimes just sit with the information.

Another massive error is trying to justify the decision during the emotional conversation. Yes, you need to explain the business rationale, but don't launch into a detailed analysis of market conditions while someone is coming to terms with losing their income. Save the business case for later – focus on the human being in front of you first.

And please, for the love of all that's holy, stop saying "this isn't personal." Of course it's personal! You're talking to a person about their livelihood. Everything about this is personal to them, even if it's "just business" to the organisation.

The Strategy That Actually Works

After years of trial and error, here's what I've found works best for managing emotions – both theirs and yours – during these conversations:

Start with acknowledgment. Before you say anything about the decision, acknowledge the difficulty of the situation. Something like, "This is going to be a difficult conversation for both of us, and I want you to know that none of this reflects on your performance or value as a person."

Be direct but not clinical. Don't bury the news in corporate speak. "We've made the difficult decision to eliminate your position" is clearer than "We're implementing a strategic restructure that impacts several roles including yours."

Pause after delivering the news. This is crucial. Don't fill the silence. Let them absorb what you've said. Count to thirty in your head if you need to.

Validate their emotional response. Whatever they're feeling is legitimate. Don't try to fix it or minimise it. If they're angry, acknowledge their anger. If they're devastated, acknowledge their devastation.

The key insight that changed everything for me was realising that my job in these conversations isn't to make people feel better about being laid off – that's impossible. My job is to preserve their dignity and provide them with the information and support they need to move forward.

Managing Your Own Emotional State

This brings me to my second controversial opinion: it's okay to show emotion during layoff conversations. Not sobbing uncontrollably, but genuine human feeling.

I used to think I had to be completely stoic, like some sort of corporate robot. But I've found that showing appropriate emotion – sadness about the situation, regret that it's come to this – actually helps people feel heard and valued. It demonstrates that their departure matters to you as a person, not just as a line item on an organisational chart.

That said, you need strategies for managing your own emotional state before, during, and after these conversations. Here's what works for me:

Before: I take ten minutes to centre myself. Sometimes that's meditation, sometimes it's just sitting quietly and remembering why this decision was necessary. I also review the person's contributions to remind myself that this conversation is about honouring their service, not just ending their employment.

During: I focus on being present. Not thinking about the next conversation or how to phrase something perfectly, but really listening to what they're saying and responding authentically.

After: I don't immediately jump into the next meeting. I take time to decompress, often by going for a walk or calling a trusted colleague to debrief. Bottling up the emotional impact of these conversations is a recipe for burnout.

The Ripple Effect on Team Morale

Something that doesn't get discussed enough is how layoff conversations affect the entire team. The people who remain are watching how you handle these situations, and it shapes their trust in leadership permanently.

I learned this lesson during a restructure in Brisbane back in 2015. We handled the individual conversations well – or so I thought – but failed to properly address the emotional needs of the remaining team. Productivity plummeted, engagement scores crashed, and we lost three more good people to voluntary resignations within six months.

The surviving employees were dealing with survivor's guilt, fear about their own job security, and resentment about increased workloads. We'd been so focused on managing the emotions of the people leaving that we neglected the emotions of the people staying.

When You Get It Wrong

Let me tell you about the time I completely botched a layoff conversation. It was with Janet, a long-term administrative assistant who'd been with the company for twelve years. I was having a particularly stressful week, rushing between meetings, and I basically treated her termination like just another agenda item.

I was cold, clinical, and dismissive of her emotional response. When she started crying, I actually said, "I know this is difficult, but we need to move through this process efficiently."

Efficiently. God, what was I thinking?

The conversation lasted maybe eight minutes. I handed her the paperwork, explained the severance, and that was it. She left that day, and I never saw her again.

A week later, I got a call from her husband. Not angry – that would have been easier to handle. He was disappointed. He told me how much respect Janet had always had for me as a leader, and how my handling of her termination had shattered that respect. He wasn't calling to complain; he was calling to help me understand the impact of my approach.

That conversation changed how I handle layoffs forever. It taught me that how you end someone's employment becomes part of their story about that chapter of their life. You can't control whether they lose their job, but you can control whether they leave feeling valued and respected.

The Practical Stuff Nobody Tells You

Beyond the emotional management, there are practical considerations that can significantly impact how these conversations unfold:

Timing matters enormously. Don't have these conversations on Fridays (gives them a whole weekend to stew), don't do them right before major holidays, and definitely don't do them first thing Monday morning when people are already dealing with Sunday night blues.

Location is crucial. Your office, not theirs. They need to be able to leave when they're ready, not sit in their workspace processing the news. Also, have tissues available. Seriously. You'd be amazed how many managers forget this basic human consideration.

Have a plan for the immediate aftermath. Who's walking them out? How are you handling access to their files? What's the communication to the rest of the team? These logistics matter because they affect how dignified the departure feels.

Building Emotional Resilience

If you're in a leadership role, particularly in industries that experience regular ups and downs, you need to build your emotional resilience around these conversations. They're part of the job, and pretending they don't affect you isn't sustainable or healthy.

I recommend developing a support network of other leaders who've been through similar experiences. There's something powerful about talking to someone who understands the weight of these decisions. Most major cities have informal groups of senior managers who meet regularly – seek them out.

Also, consider working with a coach or counsellor yourself. The emotional labour of managing layoffs is real, and it accumulates over time. Taking care of your own mental health isn't selfish; it's essential for being able to handle these situations with the care and attention they deserve.

The Long Game

Here's my final controversial opinion: how you handle layoffs defines your leadership more than almost any other single thing you'll do. Anyone can manage a team when times are good. The measure of a leader is how they behave when they have to make difficult decisions that hurt people they care about.

I've seen executives who were brilliant strategists and charismatic communicators completely lose the respect of their teams because they handled layoffs poorly. Conversely, I've seen average managers become genuinely respected leaders because they demonstrated genuine care and humanity during difficult times.

The employees who remain after a layoff are watching everything. How you treat their departing colleagues becomes their expectation for how you'll treat them if circumstances change. This isn't just about being nice – it's about building the kind of culture where people trust leadership even when times are tough.

Looking back over fifteen years of these conversations, the ones that went well had one thing in common: I treated the person across from me as a complete human being deserving of respect and dignity, not just as a business problem to be solved. It sounds simple, but it's surprisingly difficult to do when you're under pressure and dealing with your own emotions about the situation.

Every layoff conversation is an opportunity to demonstrate your values as a leader. Not through what you say, but through how you show up when showing up is hard. That's the test that really matters.

---

Read More Here:

• Leadership Skills for Supervisors - Essential training for developing management capabilities
• Workplace Training Resources - Professional development insights and strategies